Action and Combat - Open Discussion

118 posts / 0 new
Last post
o11o1 o11o1's picture
Full Defense against PSI when

Full Defense against PSI when you're not PSI looks a lot like repeating some sort of mantra or imagining brick walls.

A slight smell of ions....

eaton eaton's picture
So, in contrast to my usual

So, in contrast to my usual high-falutin' mechanics theory, I've got some concrete feedback on the combat chapter. I really like the explicit list of "Weapon Traits" like Fixed, Armor Piercing, No Close Range, and so on. Some additions that I think would be useful to add to that table:

Single-Use: Breaks or becomes unusable after one attack. (Used by disposable launchers)
Fragile: Snaps, breaks, or becomes unusable on superior failures. (used by the monofilament garotte)
Accurate: No range modifiers apply to attacks with this weapon. (Used by accushot ammo)

It's a little bit of planning ahead, but treating all three as distinct weapon traits makes mixing and matching certain special behaviors on homebrew weapons (or future expansions) more straightforward.

DivineWrath DivineWrath's picture
Some feedback.

Some feedback.

p. 33

Quote:
Most synthmorphs and objects do not heal on their own and must
be repaired. Some are equipped with self-repair systems that func-
tion the same as medichines (p. XX). Repair spray can be used to
make fixes and functions the same as nanobandages (max 3 uses
per day). Synthmorphs and objects may also be repaired in a nano-
fabrication machine with the appropriate blueprints; treat this the
same as a healing vat.

Emphasis mine.

You might want to rethink that line. If fabrication times are the same for EP2 as they were in EP1, then its often quicker to print a new synthmorph or object than to use healing vat times.

p. 33-34

Quote:
Physical Repair: Manually repairing a synthmorph or object
requires a Hardware Test using a field appropriate to the item
(Hardware: Robotics for synthmorphs and bots, Hardware:
Aerospace for aircraft, etc.). Repair is a task action with a timeframe
of 1 hour per 5 points of damage being restored, plus 8 hours
per wound. Appropriate modifiers should be applied, based on
conditions and available tools.

Do you need to repair everything in one go, or can you pick and choose what to repair? What if you had only 4 hours to do repairs for a 12 hour repair job?

ubik2 ubik2's picture
DivineWrath wrote:If

DivineWrath wrote:
If fabrication times are the same for EP2 as they were in EP1, then its often quicker to print a new synthmorph or object than to use healing vat times.

Healing Vats take "2 hours / wound" (Actions and Combat: page 33). Fabrication time for a synthmorph is "1 week + 1 per MP" (Acquiring Gear and Morphs: page 5).

If there's missing limbs (2 days to replace), it looks like it's still faster to repair. If the whole body is missing, it will take 30 days to repair, so in that case, for an inexpensive morph (Case/Dragonfly/Synth), you'd probably just replace it, but for any of the other synthmorphs, it's better to repair.

There's also the strain of resleeving (which isn't needed if you stay in the nanofab), but I imagine you'd want a new shell anyhow while that one is being repaired, if it will take more than a couple days.

For an object of Major complexity, you're looking at 1 day to fabricate a new one, so if the object is missing limbs, you'd replace it, but if it's just wounded, you'd repair it. A Moderate complexity object should be repaired with 4 or fewer wounds. A Minor complexity object should only be repaired if it has one or fewer wounds.

less3r less3r's picture
Semi-Auto

Does it say anywhere in there if weapons fired in Semi-Auto mode still get two attacks / two attack rolls for every Attack Complex Action? If so I (clearly) didn't see it.

Grim G Grim G's picture
eaton wrote:So, in contrast

eaton wrote:
So, in contrast to my usual high-falutin' mechanics theory, I've got some concrete feedback on the combat chapter. I really like the explicit list of "Weapon Traits" like Fixed, Armor Piercing, No Close Range, and so on. Some additions that I think would be useful to add to that table:

Single-Use: Breaks or becomes unusable after one attack. (Used by disposable launchers)
Fragile: Snaps, breaks, or becomes unusable on superior failures. (used by the monofilament garotte)
Accurate: No range modifiers apply to attacks with this weapon. (Used by accushot ammo)

It's a little bit of planning ahead, but treating all three as distinct weapon traits makes mixing and matching certain special behaviors on homebrew weapons (or future expansions) more straightforward.


I never understood the idea of "disposable" launchers. I mean, yeah the ammo would probably be a pain to carry around, but to say there's no way to reload it seems crazy.
swordchucks swordchucks's picture
Finally... But only half way.

I'll admit that I've been sort of avoiding this chapter, or, at least, saving it for last. So... fresh eyes on it. This is just the first half of it, too. Hopefully, I'll get through the rest soon.

p2 - Step 1: Declare Attack
The first sentence is... a little odd. "On their turn in the Initiative order, a character may initiate an attack using the attack complex action." might be better. Similarly, "the nature of the attack must be declared" feels weird. Maybe "The target or targets and method of attack must be declared as part of the attack action, which will determine the skill which is rolled against."

p2 - Step 2: Declare Defense
What do you use to avoid an explosion? That comes up enough that a brief mention here wouldn't be weird.

p2 - Step 5: Determine Result
To avoid confusion, mention of the attacker's critical beating a higher, non-critical success by the defender is missing. It refers back to Opposed Tests here, but some of the other aspects are glossed over (namely, ties) so it may have newer players a bit confused. The same note applies to the summary on p3.

p2 - Step 6: Roll Damage
I'd add something in this bit harkening to the bonus damage for autofire. "Superior results and autofire bonuses may increase..." maybe?

p2 - Step 9: Determine Wounds
"two or more factors beyond" is just odd phrasing. I know what it means from EP1, but I'm not sure a new player would. I'd expect to see the word "multiples" in here, but I'm kind of drawing a blank on how to make it work.

p3 - Melee Combat
It's just fluff, but it might be worth a throw-away line about how melee weapons are still in use because they're easy to conceal and obtain, even on fairly strict habitats. Really, it's the main reason you see folks with axes and batons in a game.

p3 - Melee Ware
Under the Melee Weapons heading, it has a note about the skill used. Should we get one about using the Melee skill under this heading, too?

p3 - Piston Spike
I think I'm in love with the piston spike that leaves a minigrenade in the hole it makes.

p4 - Melee Attacks
Is there any reason Eelware doesn't have an average damage? Unarmed gets one and it has the same die type. Mention of how the * pistons interact with armor when they deliver their grenade would be nice. I assume that if the spear gets through the armor on the attack, then the grenade ignores the armor. However, I can see it being an argument.

p3-5 - Melee Combat
One thing I don't like a whole lot about the current system is that there's no nod to morph in the melee combat section. A fury with a sword hits just as hard as a flat. That's... not really great. The only way to excel in melee combat is to have more arms and thus more weapons.

p6 - Ammunition and Reloading
This feels like an unnecessary shift. You're trading one kind of complexity for a different kind of complexity and it doesn't make a huge amount of simulationist sense, either. Is having weapons have "shots" and having the firing modes consume x shots such an issue?

p6 - Indirect Fire
Reading this, it seems like you can use indirect fire with any weapon. Is that intentional?

p7 - Ranged Modifiers
I like that smartlink is now assumed in the base roll. You probably do need to add "Single Shot" to the firing modes section (probably on the same line as SA).

p8 - Battle Laser
I'd appreciate some clarity on what "mounted" means in this context. Can a morph of a certain size mount it? Vehicle only?

p8 - Laser Pulser
Does the plasma effect work in vacuum?

p8 - Microwave Agonizer
What lets you ignore the "move away" effect? If this is just the Pain effect, it may be clearer to cite that here.

p8 - Beam and Spray Weapons
Overall, I like that the weapons are more universally useful now. The Laser Pulser is at least as potent as a base machine pistol, though larger and without ammo options. That's a lot better than it was in EP1.

p8 - Freezer/Shards & Drugs/Toxins
One thing about these guys in EP1 was always that the cost of using toxins/drugs in spray weapons was insanely expensive. Some info on how this works (cost-wise) in this edition will be very necessary. I'm happy for them to be more expensive... just not insanely expensive.

p10 - Polyguns
I'm less interested in these weapons as shapeshifting between weapons and more interested in their ability to assume less detectable forms. I'd like to see the rules on that.

p16 - Inspire
I don't see why you can't do this for fellow PCs. It'd give the social character something to do.

p17 - Confused
I've... never really been a fan of this type of condition. Someone with their wits scrambled is more likely to hunker down (which is sort or like the low result, but not quite) or stumble around aimlessly (probably out of cover, if they were in it).

Surly Surly's picture
Is there a particular reason

Is there a particular reason the Laser Pulser and Particle Beam have knockdown? Makes sense for the laser pulser's stun mode, but I don't don't see how a laser or reasonable-sized particle beam can carry enough momentum to knock someone down. Maybe give them better blinding capabilities?

Should multiple ranged weapons work like burst attacks, rather than multiple separate attacks? Same way extra melee weapons work, faster to resolve, and reduces ambidexterous-octomorph shenanigans.

Editing issue - the >>>+30? at the bottom of p. 23.

I like the way time has become a resource. The downtime and stuff-acquisition systems, the armor mods, current Rep and Resources, all converge on making the amount of time you have to get stuff before a mission as much something to manage as wealth is. I think it works very well! That and morph points seem to naturally lead to well-balanced groups and good pacing.

ubik2 ubik2's picture
Grim G wrote:I never

Grim G wrote:
I never understood the idea of "disposable" launchers. I mean, yeah the ammo would probably be a pain to carry around, but to say there's no way to reload it seems crazy.

For weapons like the M72 LAW, the launcher is basically just part of the ammunition. After shooting the rocket, nobody wants to carry around the empty tube until they get back and resupply. If they need 2 rockets, they just grab 2 of the disposable launchers (each loaded with the one shot).

There's also some safety benefits, in case the tube gets damaged or warped by the exhaust. The launcher is a bit like the brass case for bullets. You can collect them, and reuse them, but most people don't bother.

ubik2 ubik2's picture
swordchucks wrote:p2 - Step 9

swordchucks wrote:
p2 - Step 9: Determine Wounds
"two or more factors beyond" is just odd phrasing. I know what it means from EP1, but I'm not sure a new player would. I'd expect to see the word "multiples" in here, but I'm kind of drawing a blank on how to make it work.

"two or more multiples of" would make sense to me, as would "two or more times". Factors is really the other direction (divisors).

swordchucks wrote:

p3-5 - Melee Combat
One thing I don't like a whole lot about the current system is that there's no nod to morph in the melee combat section. A fury with a sword hits just as hard as a flat. That's... not really great. The only way to excel in melee combat is to have more arms and thus more weapons.

It would be nice if you could spend a Vigor point to add 1d6 to the damage of a melee attack, though it's probably not that optimal.

The Muscle Augmentation ware (from the Enforcer gear set) does provide +1d6 DV.

swordchucks wrote:
p8 - Laser Pulser
Does the plasma effect work in vacuum?

You've turned the outer layer of the target into plasma. I don't think there's enough time for this to appreciably diffuse into the vacuum before that second blast of energy hits it (just as there's not enough time for it to diffuse into the atmosphere).

Surly wrote:
Is there a particular reason the Laser Pulser and Particle Beam have knockdown? Makes sense for the laser pulser's stun mode, but I don't don't see how a laser or reasonable-sized particle beam can carry enough momentum to knock someone down. Maybe give them better blinding capabilities?

I'm not certain of the model, but I imagine what's happening is that each pulse of the laser (non PEP mode) is causing a layer of the target to explode, then a small delay for the area to clear, and another blast of energy, and another tiny explosion. It's those surface explosions that knock them down, and the momentum comes from their armor (or flesh).

I don't know how you would make a particle beam work in atmosphere, but the vacuum version would cause knockback the same way as the laser. The outer layer of the target explodes, knocking them down. At these energy densities, it's like all armor is reactive armor, which is part of why it's hard to make these weapons as effective as the lower speed kinetic weapons. I think that for particle beams in atmosphere, you'd essentially fire some pre-beam that blasts all the air out of the way (hole-boring), eventually clearing a relatively obstacle free path to your target.

Trappedinwikipedia Trappedinwikipedia's picture
IIRC charged particle beams

IIRC charged particle beams are self-focusing in atmosphere, so nothing fancy required.

ThatWhichNeverWas ThatWhichNeverWas's picture
One day I will learn to post quickly. This is not that day.

less3r wrote:
Does it say anywhere in there if weapons fired in Semi-Auto mode still get two attacks / two attack rolls for every Attack Complex Action? If so I (clearly) didn't see it.

I think they don't - they simply aren't subject to SS's 1 shot/round restriction.

-----

I'll try and post more tomorrow, but in advance of that:
Can we PLEASE change the Freezer so that targets are [Grappled] instead of [Paralyzed]? It would make things so much easier (and make it less of a on-hit-kill monster).

Beyond that, I'd kinda like to see it removed as a unique weapon - it can be a Sprayer loaded with the Freezer-Foam chemical.
Then we can have freezer grenades, Spray cans for instant cover... all sorts of fun toys.

In the past we've had to compensate for weaknesses, finding quick solutions that only benefit a few.
But what if we never need to feel weak or morally conflicted again?

DivineWrath DivineWrath's picture
ubik2 wrote:DivineWrath wrote

ubik2 wrote:
DivineWrath wrote:
If fabrication times are the same for EP2 as they were in EP1, then its often quicker to print a new synthmorph or object than to use healing vat times.

Healing Vats take "2 hours / wound" (Actions and Combat: page 33). Fabrication time for a synthmorph is "1 week + 1 per MP" (Acquiring Gear and Morphs: page 5).

If there's missing limbs (2 days to replace), it looks like it's still faster to repair. If the whole body is missing, it will take 30 days to repair, so in that case, for an inexpensive morph (Case/Dragonfly/Synth), you'd probably just replace it, but for any of the other synthmorphs, it's better to repair.

There's also the strain of resleeving (which isn't needed if you stay in the nanofab), but I imagine you'd want a new shell anyhow while that one is being repaired, if it will take more than a couple days.

For an object of Major complexity, you're looking at 1 day to fabricate a new one, so if the object is missing limbs, you'd replace it, but if it's just wounded, you'd repair it. A Moderate complexity object should be repaired with 4 or fewer wounds. A Minor complexity object should only be repaired if it has one or fewer wounds.

The more I read this, the more I realize that I'm not sure what the different rates are for building stuff. It isn't very clear. Is the one week for building synthmorph in a garage using spare parts, for being printed by a CM machine, or building everything from nothing (print the parts instead of using off the shelf parts).

less3r less3r's picture
Per Acquiring Gear and Morphs

DivineWrath wrote:
ubik2 wrote:

Healing Vats take "2 hours / wound" (Actions and Combat: page 33). Fabrication time for a synthmorph is "1 week + 1 per MP" (Acquiring Gear and Morphs: page 5).

If there's missing limbs (2 days to replace), it looks like it's still faster to repair. If the whole body is missing, it will take 30 days to repair, so in that case, for an inexpensive morph (Case/Dragonfly/Synth), you'd probably just replace it, but for any of the other synthmorphs, it's better to repair.

There's also the strain of resleeving (which isn't needed if you stay in the nanofab), but I imagine you'd want a new shell anyhow while that one is being repaired, if it will take more than a couple days.

For an object of Major complexity, you're looking at 1 day to fabricate a new one, so if the object is missing limbs, you'd replace it, but if it's just wounded, you'd repair it. A Moderate complexity object should be repaired with 4 or fewer wounds. A Minor complexity object should only be repaired if it has one or fewer wounds.

The more I read this, the more I realize that I'm not sure what the different rates are for building stuff. It isn't very clear. Is the one week for building synthmorph in a garage using spare parts, for being printed by a CM machine, or building everything from nothing (print the parts instead of using off the shelf parts).

Per Acquiring Gear and Morphs, page 5 (June 8 version)

"Making Morphs" Section

Building a synth requires blueprints and a nanofabricator (I assume medical facility is for bio only).

Timeframe = (1+MP) weeks to build a synth. (Skills required are Hardware: Robotics and Program)

So the rules assume printing parts. This makes sense for the lore, since only hypercorps and the outer system have access to this level of printing. I suppose morphs are too complex to just use spare parts.

ThatWhichNeverWas ThatWhichNeverWas's picture
Okay, finally have some time.

First, the quick stuff:

- As I mentioned before, make the freezer Grapple instead of Paralysing so that the target has a way out.

- Include a note by Fray/Full defence saying whether bonuses to Fray are applied Before or After it's halved vs ranged attacks.

- Have cover apply a bonus to Fray instead of a penalty to hit.

- Make an explicit upper limit to 'Beyond Range', presumably if it would entail a penalty greater than -60.

- Put Ranged Attacks before Melee Attacks, and put the Melee Rules before the Melee Ware/Weapons so that both subsections follow the same format.

- Move the 'Weapon Traits' and 'Conditions' lists to the Ranged Combat rules (after Suppressive Fire for example), so that readers understand what the keywords mean before they're used descriptively.

- This might be just me, but can we rename 'Hollow-Point' smart ammo to 'Anti-Personnel'?

- In the 'Specific Target' called shot subsection, have it point to the Conditions list (subject to GM approval) rather than simply using Blinding as an example.

- Move the rules for wielding extra Ranged/Melee weapons to the Ranged Attacks and Melee Attacks subsections respectively.

- List the Action Types used for Social Attacks in combat.

- Add a note to the Blindness or Healing and Repair section saying how long it takes to recover from inflicted blindness.
As a personal preference, I'd make this pretty quick, on the scale of a hour or two assuming biomods are present. This would make the Status less insanely powerful, and can be justified due to the functional simplicity of the repair – a few layers of cells need replacing, not bulk tissue.
If it comes up, I'd do the same for deafness due to damage to the eardrum or other membranes.

----- Action Economy -----

I put this in the other thread, but I really want to see more Quick Action options. I won't repeat the other thread too much, but here are some things I think would be good choices from this section:

- Calling a Shot (instead of the -10 modifier)
- Aggressive Melee Attacks (instead of the Fray penalty)
- Firing Full Auto (Having to stabilise the weapon, makes Not Firing Full Auto an actual choice)
- Stabilising a Fixed Weapon (Can fire without the -20 to hit)
- Ducking behind cover (Increases effective cover modifier)
- BlindSight (Roll perception, success reduces penalties for blindness until the next turn)

----- Healing and Repair -----

I don't know if this is a super idea, but would it be possible to attach healing to the recharge system instead of a general timeframe?
This would reduce the tome/bookkeeping, and re-enforce the concept of Recharges as low-exertion moments where the Morph can put itself to rights.
Of the top of my head, I'd suggest:
- No Biomods – 1d10 Per Long Recharge
- Biomods – 1d6 per Short Recharge, 1d10 Per Long Recharge
- Medichines - 1d10 per Short Recharge, 4d10 Per Long Recharge

Also, please change the Poor/Harsh Conditions table entries, the multiplier is misleading.

----- Mental Stress -----

This is a crosspost (partial copy/past too) with the Psi thread, but I'd like to see Stress retooled to represent short-term rather than long-term conditions.
This means the 'healing' rate would be significantly increased to be on par with Durability, but damaging effects would become more common.
Most significantly, this would mean that effects like Shocking and Stunning attacks, Sedatives and other drugs, Sleight-based attacks, and Microwave Agonizer Pain would all inflict Stress.
Running out of SV would result in loss of conciousness, or another effect defined by the source (for example, a combat drug could make the target go into a berserker rage) so long as the effect is the character becoming uncontrollable or otherwise leaving play.

Long term effects would then use a variant on the Infection Rating/Strain system; the character has an 'Instability' rating equal to 10 +20 for each Disorder they possess. Other ego traits could also change this base value, and short term bonuses/penalties would come from the situation.
When the character encounters a source of stress/instability, they have to roll against this value to avoid triggering their disorder's associated behaviours.
Failing to comply with their compulsions inflicts SV.

As characters are exposed to disturbing situations they become more and more burdened with psychological problems (negative traits), which in turn affect their actions/effectiveness in-game, until they finally break down (Base Instability 100>), and stop being a player character.

Would this be doable, assuming it makes sense?

In the past we've had to compensate for weaknesses, finding quick solutions that only benefit a few.
But what if we never need to feel weak or morally conflicted again?

ubik2 ubik2's picture
less3r wrote:So the rules

less3r wrote:
So the rules assume printing parts. This makes sense for the lore, since only hypercorps and the outer system have access to this level of printing. I suppose morphs are too complex to just use spare parts.

I actually think there aren't usually spare parts in this futuristic world. You have feedstock, and you print what you need on the fly. When you decommission a robot, you don't keep the working parts, you just put them all in the recycler (where they become feedstock), and next time you need an arm, you print the one you need.

Of course, spare parts exist for more reasons than this. We're not given fabrication times for really simple stuff, but if your tire just blew up, you probably don't want to wait 2 hours for a new one. It's possible you have a fabber for that that can build you a new tire fast, but otherwise, you would probably carry a spare.

The books don't mention fabrication of trivial items that might be required for repair, but presumably these time costs are part of the task timeframe. That would mean it doesn't actually take 2 hours to print the new tire you need, in which case, you might not need a spare after all.

ubik2 ubik2's picture
ThatWhichNeverWas wrote:-

ThatWhichNeverWas wrote:
- Have cover apply a bonus to Fray instead of a penalty to hit

This doesn't handle the case where the defender isn't aware. In reality, it affects both rolls (the attacker needs to shoot at a smaller area, and the defender has an easy place to get to to avoid being hit). That seems like overkill for game rules, though.

ThatWhichNeverWas wrote:
- Make an explicit upper limit to 'Beyond Range', presumably if it would entail a penalty greater than -60.

Probably want to do something about the accushot ammo interaction here, but maybe you just mean no more than 6 range increments. Perhaps the range penalties should also apply even in zero-g, since the arc you need to hit does shrink. I think the recent sniper rifle record would have been at -70 (range increment 500m), but a limit of -60 makes more sense in this game.

ThatWhichNeverWas wrote:
- Calling a Shot (instead of the -10 modifier)

Is there a mechanical difference between this and taking quick aim (+10) together with a called shot (-10) for a net 0 modifier?

Pages